Full index of posts »
StockTalks
-
Any thoughts on $LNKD acquiring SlideShare?
May 3, 2012
-
David Brooks' article on The Two Economies is a must-read, whether or not you agree. http://nyti.ms/HxK8N2 Do you agree with it?
Apr 10, 2012
-
We're testing two changes to StockTalks:
Apr 10, 2012
Latest Comments
-
bernardpalmer on Rethinking how Seeking Alpha calculates Top Commenters Thiazole,You said "This will force people ...
-
Neil459 on Rethinking how Seeking Alpha calculates Top Commenters I really like this idea.
-
thiazole on Rethinking how Seeking Alpha calculates Top Commenters Here's a crazy idea. Don't remove anything from...
-
Dialectical Materialist on Rethinking how Seeking Alpha calculates Top Commenters "However, I still fail to see how changes ...
-
robert.b.ferguson on Rethinking how Seeking Alpha calculates Top Commenters All of that is true and I don't have any proble...
Most Commented
- How Should We Improve Seeking Alpha's Comment Rating System? (98 Comments)
- Why don't IR people use Seeking Alpha? (43 Comments)
- Rethinking how Seeking Alpha calculates Top Commenters (33 Comments)
- How to Measure a Website's Success (8 Comments)
- Upgrading Our Daily Email (7 Comments)
Posts by Themes
About Seeking Alpha,
blog platforms,
business intelligence,
comment ratings,
community,
contributors,
emails,
followers/following,
instablogs,
investor relations,
Market Currents,
media,
metrics,
paid content,
portfolio-strategy-asset-allocation,
press,
spam,
StockTalk,
transcripts,
Transcripts,
twitter,
usability,
user engagement,
What's New,
Whats New
Instablogs are Seeking Alpha's free blogging platform customized for finance, with instant set up and exposure to millions of readers interested in the financial markets. Publish your own instablog in minutes.













View David Jackson's Instablogs on:
This Made My Day
"I am writing to let you know that SeekingAlpha has helped me rethink, reposition, and reinvent my entire financial existence in a very positive way. For many years until this past summer, I would occasionally happen on SA and read a few articles; I always found them interesting and stimulating, but I never followed up in any way. As a result of a significant change in my financial circumstances, however, I suddenly picked up on SA a couple of months ago and since then, it's been one huge home run for me. I visit SA daily and find it to be the best, richest, most honest, and most flexible financial website for personal investing. As a direct result of SA, I have rediscovered valuable things about stock investing that I learned 35 to 40 years ago, but forgot or put aside over time. It's all coming back to me now thanks to the marvellous authors and community on SA. And the results show in my personal investment portfolio--it's impressed even my personal investment advisor! SA is an excellent resource and I hope it's around for a very long time to come. Thanks to you and your team for your excellent efforts."
Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours.
Rethinking how Seeking Alpha calculates Top Commenters
Until now, we were calculating Top Commenters by a simple tally of the number of "likes" their comments received. The problem with that is that there are many groups on Seeking Alpha who repeatedly "like" their own members' comments, so the number of likes might not be an accurate recognition of comment quality.
So we've decided to re-evaluate the algorithm we use to calculate Top Commenters. I suspect we'll still base the rankings on "likes", but we can be far more sophisticated, for example by taking account of the "authority" of the person who votes with a "like". (Think aboout Google's calculations of Page Rank based on links and the authority of the linking site.)
While we rethink this, we're removing the Top Commenters badges and the link to the Top Commenters leaderboard in the footer of the site. But we're still storing all the data about "likes", so that when we launch the new algorithm it will take account of up to date data.
If you have any thoughts about how we should calculate Top Commenters, we'd love to hear your ideas - please leave a comment below.
Bloomberg reports when SA moves stocks